Comparison · Aspera and Signiant
IBM Aspera on Cloud and Signiant Media Shuttle are what a studio's IT department buys: accelerated transfer over UDP, portals, single sign-on, automation, round-the-clock support, and a contract. Both can run against storage you already own. Klarsend covers one slice of that: a person with a file in Azure Blob or S3 who needs to hand it to someone today, with a link they can take back. Whether you need the platform or the slice is mostly a question of scale, and of who is paying.
| IBM Aspera on Cloud | Signiant Media Shuttle | Klarsend Send | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A transfer platform: packages, shared workspaces, FASP acceleration, on IBM-hosted storage or storage you attach. | A transfer SaaS: Send, Share and Submit portals on storage you supply, accelerated by the Signiant App. | A revocable short link to one file or folder in your Azure Blob or S3 storage, opened in any browser. Also a receive link, for files coming in. |
| Pricing | Pay as you go from $1.07 per GB transferred, egress included. Essentials from $22.10 a month on a plan with 1 TB a year. Standard Plus from $660 a month on a plan with 6 TB a year. Lite, self-managed, from $11,916 a year. 14-day trial up to 50 GB. | Annual subscription, users sold in blocks. Small Business from $13,000 a year. Professional from $25,000 a year, with 25 TB a year of cloud payload. Enterprise on quote, with 100 TB. Storage is yours and billed by your provider. | Free: 10 active links at a time. Premium: €6 a month, VAT included, unlimited active links. Provider egress is paid to your provider and estimated before you send. |
| Where the file travels | Through IBM's transfer service, or your own Aspera server, to the recipient. | Through Signiant's transfer servers between the Signiant App and your storage. App-less transfers route through the Media Shuttle cloud. | Straight from your storage to the recipient. Klarsend's servers never see file bytes. |
| Your own storage | Yes: Azure Blob, S3 and others attach to the Aspera Transfer Service with an access key or SAS URL, or you tether your own transfer server. IBM can also host the storage. | Yes: on-premises, AWS, Azure or Google Cloud, assigned per portal. Signiant does not sell storage. | Yes, and only that. Klarsend has no storage of its own. |
| Who holds your storage credentials | IBM's transfer service, to move files on your behalf. | Signiant's service, which attaches your storage with your cloud credentials. | You. They are encrypted on your device; the server stores ciphertext it cannot read. |
| What the recipient needs | IBM Aspera Connect, a desktop client with a browser extension. If the admin enables the HTTP Gateway, a browser alone works, without resume and without the transfer monitor, and folders must be zipped first. | The Signiant App, which the portal prompts them to install. An app-less option exists for single files and counts against the cloud payload allowance. | A browser. Nothing to install on any plan. Folders download file by file or as a zip assembled in the browser. |
| Take a link back | Not stated on the pricing page, which lists file deletion policies per plan. | Not stated on the pricing page; admins control access to content. | Yes, on every plan. A revoked short link stops working for new opens immediately. It cannot recall a download already in progress. |
| Who opened it | Transfer monitoring and activity reporting; detail varies by plan. | Member activity tracking in the admin dashboard. | Per link: opened, downloaded, approximate country, browser or device, for seven days. |
| Receiving files | Yes, through packages sent to you and shared workspaces. | Yes, through Submit portals, with an iOS app. | Yes, in its simplest form: a receive link the sender opens in a browser, writing straight into your Azure container with a create-and-write-only credential. A link, not a portal; not on S3 yet. |
| Automation and APIs | Workflows on Standard Plus and above; none on Pay as you go or Essentials. | Automation APIs and the Media Shuttle SDK on Enterprise. | None. Klarsend is a person sending to a person. |
| Single sign-on and teams | Workspaces and groups; single sign-on supported. | SAML 2.0 single sign-on on Enterprise; users in blocks of ten. | Not today. Accounts are individual, with a passkey. |
| Setup | Account and organisation, storage attached or IBM-hosted, Connect on every sender's and recipient's machine. | Contract, portals, storage attachment, the Signiant App on every machine. | An account with a passkey, a storage connection, one CORS rule, once. About ten minutes. |
| Support | IBM support, by plan. | 24/7 support on every tier; a dedicated success manager on Professional. | Email. No contract and no service-level agreement. |
A 400 GB master goes to three recipients, each downloading once: 1,200 GB out.
The platforms are not expensive by accident; the fee buys acceleration, portals, administration and a vendor who answers the phone. The arithmetic turns on how often you send. At a dozen jobs like this a year, Signiant's fee divides into about $1,083 per job. At a dozen a month it divides into about $90, and at that volume a platform with portals and automation is probably what you want anyway.
For a studio pipeline, no. Klarsend has no acceleration, no submission portals, no automation, no single sign-on and no contract, and it is not trying to grow them. For a person who has a file in a bucket and a colleague who needs it, yes: the link is live in under a minute, the recipient needs nothing but a browser, you can take the link back, and the only invoice is your provider's egress. Many teams on an enterprise platform still reach for a consumer tool when the request comes from outside the pipeline; Klarsend is for that request, without handing the file to a third party.
Move data fast over bad links, with UDP transport that fills a long-haul connection where plain HTTPS stalls on packet loss. Run transfers between systems with no person at either end. Receive files from many contributors through managed portals; Klarsend’s receive link covers one client sending into one container, and nothing more. Administer hundreds of users with single sign-on, groups and policies. Offer SDKs and APIs to wire into a media asset manager. Resume anything, on any plan. And come with the implementation help, support contract and vendor paperwork that a procurement team expects. Aspera can also host the storage if you have none.
Put no transfer server in the path at all: the bytes go from your storage to the recipient and nowhere else. Keep your storage credentials unreadable to the service, encrypted on your device, with the encrypting code published so you can check. Ask the recipient to install nothing, on any plan. Start free, with no contract, in about ten minutes. And let you revoke a link and see who opened it without an annual fee.
Get started
Connect it, send a link, revoke it — in under ten minutes, with no card and no email address.
The core stays free. Premium is €6 a month, VAT included — pricing · refund policy.